10 Make Ahead Thanksgiving Desserts You'll Be Glad You Finished Early

Make-ahead Thanksgiving desserts are the easiest way to take pressure off the holiday because they hold their structure, stay flavorful, and give you a calm morning. These are the recipes I trust most when I want dessert finished early without losing the homemade feel my family loves.

A woman with medium-length dark brown hair and fair skin smiling with trees behind her.

WANT TO SAVE THIS RECIPE?

I’ll email it to you for later, and periodically send recipes and updates.

Note from Erin

The first few years I hosted Thanksgiving were packed with last-minute baking and way too much stress, and I finally realized dessert didn't need to be part of that chaos.

The trick is choosing recipes that hold their texture and flavor after a full chill. Custard pies, bars, and cheesecakes all actually get better when they rest overnight, and adding a no-bake option lets you use your oven for everything else you're cooking.

Once I started planning this way, Thanksgiving morning were no longer chaotic, and I could enjoy my coffee and the parade without rushing around the kitchen.

Simple black outline drawing of a kitchen whisk with a handle and looped wires.

Expert Tips for Making Thanksgiving Desserts Ahead

Chill your desserts on a completely flat surface so the filling settles evenly. A tilted pan will make bars or cheesecakes set at an angle.
Once everything is cold, move your desserts away from any warm items. Quick temperature swings can cause condensation on pies and cheesecakes.
If refrigerator space gets tight, place a baking sheet on top of your pies or bars so you can safely stack lighter items without damaging the surface.

Desserts that Can be Made 3+ Days Ahead

If you really want to feel like you've got everything under control, make these recipes the weekend before Thanksgiving!

A slice of pumpkin cheesecake with caramel sauce and chopped nuts on top, served on a white plate.

Pumpkin Pecan Cheesecake

Cheesecake always needs time to chill, and the flavor develops as it sets. The topping can even be made a day or two in advance. It will still have a gooey caramel texture when you're ready to serve it.

Pumpkin Pecan Cheesecake Recipe

Three stacked dessert bars with chocolate chips and nuts on a white plate, with more bars in the background.

Chocolate Pecan Pie Bars

These bars have a buttery shortbread base with a chocolate pecan filling, and keep their texture longer than a traditional pie. They also travel well!

Pecan Pie Bar Recipe

Buckeye Bars

Creamy peanut butter topped with smooth chocolate that stays firm and slices easily after chilling. These bars are one of the simplest desserts to prepare early.

Buckeye Bar Recipe

A square pumpkin cheesecake bar showing ¼-inch thick graham cracker crust, creamy filling, topped with whipped cream.

No Bake Pumpkin Cheesecake Bars

A creamy pumpkin filling on a graham cracker crust made in under 15 minutes that firms completely in the refrigerator.

Cheesecake Bar Recipe

Two peach-colored sparkle shapes on a light gray background.

Make your pie crust in advance, too! I like to make my favorite flaky pie crust recipe months ahead and store it in the freezer, but the dough can also be refrigerated for 5 days.

Recipes Made Up to 2 Days Ahead

Pumpkin Pie

A classic custard pie like this creamy pumpkin pie becomes easier to slice once fully chilled. The spices also settle into a balanced flavor.

Pumpkin Pie Recipe

Top Recipe

Sweet Potato Pie

This is the number one recipe on my site over Thanksgiving! It's a classic Southern Thanksgiving dessert that holds up really well!

Pie Recipe

Sugar Cream Pie

This is another family favorite holiday pie that we love to make in advance. Even the caramelized cinnamon sugar topping holds up well!

Sugar Cream Pie Recipe

Thanksgiving Desserts Made 1 Day Early

A slice of spiced pumpkin cake with a thick layer of cream cheese frosting on a ceramic plate, showcasing the simplicity of a one bowl cake.

Pumpkin Olive Oil Cake

A tender, moist pumpkin cake made with olive oil, so it stays soft even after resting overnight. It holds its texture well and is easy to frost the day before.

Pumpkin Cake Recipe

Sweet Potato Dump Cake

A sweet potato filling topped with buttery cake mix that settles together as it cools. The texture becomes even more cohesive by the next day, and it reheats without drying out.

Sweet Potato Dump Cake

Plate of peach cobbler with juicy peaches and flaky pie crust topped with a scoop of vanilla ice cream.

Easy Peach Cobbler

A classic peach cobbler with a flaky pie crust that reheats without losing texture, or you can serve it chilled if you prefer a firmer filling.

Peach Cobbler Recipe

Don't Forget Your Toppings!

Whipped Cream

Homemade whipped cream is serious business in my family. I have to make a giant bowl to go along with our Thanksgiving desserts! I've found that by adding a touch of cream of tartar I can make it a day in advance and it will still be fluffy the next day.

Whipped Cream Recipe